Triple talaq practiced for 1400 years, how is it unconstitutional: AIMPLB

"We will come out with a law to regulate the marriage and divorce among Muslim community", the Attorney General Mukul Rohatgi, appearing for Centre, said.

"If Hindus faith about Rama's birth at Ayodhya can't be questioned, then triple talaq, a matter of faith for Muslims, shouldn't be", Kapil Sibal said.

Citing limited time, the bench said it would focus on the validity of triple talaq, leaving other two issues for a later date.

At this, Chief Justice Khehar said that the top court was not just the "guardian to the Constitution but also that of the Minorities Act".

The AG also told the apex court that Triple Talaq violated the Muslim women's right to equality within the community, and also within the country.

Earlier in the day, the apex court bench also comprising Justices Kurian Joseph, R F Nariman, U U Lalit and Abdul Nazeer, said it was keeping open the issues of practice of polygamy and "nikah halala" among Muslims for adjudication in future, as the Centre insisted on judicial deliberations on these aspects as well.

The court had said on Thursday it would only look into triple talaq.

In its last hearing on Friday, the apex court had observed that triple talaq was the "worst" and "not a desirable" way to end marriages among Muslims.


Supporting the stance of ending the practice of triple talaq, the Allahabad High Court had earlier asserted that the rights of any person, including Muslim women, can not be violated in the name of "personal law". Muslims are practicing it for last 1400 years. The national Law Commission previous year sought public views on whether to abolish the practice, triggering a debate between politicians and religious leaders.

Pointing to the perils involved in undertaking such an exercise, Sibal said, "Hindus believe that Lord Ram was born in Ayodhya".

In this light, the argument put forward by Sibal is extremely problematic because the chief contention against instant triple talaq is precisely that it allows the strangling hold of patriarchal provisions and discriminates against Muslim women, who have no legal recourse once instant talaq is thrust upon them. "Hence, there was no question of constitutional morality and equity", Sibal argued.

"There was a talk that whether Triple Talaq is legitimate unavoidably". If the Nikahnama is changed by some statute, I would say that you are changing my very faith, but if I agree to that change on an individual basis, it is okay. Immediately after a few years of the death of Prophet Muhammad, the companions of Prophet Muhammad talked about triple talaq.

"We can not go into rights and wrongs because my faith does not allow this", Sibal said.

The apex court has fixed a six-day schedule for hearing in which three days would be available for those challenging triple talaq and three days for those defending it.

The bench said two other forms of divorce have some safeguards but whether triple talaq had such safeguards?


Popular
  • Si Woo Kim's win lands punter a fortune

    A day after he missed just one fairway and to tied Holmes at 9-under, Kyle Stanley found just six of 14 fairways to shoot 75. While numerous top contenders came unglued, Kim stoically made his way around TPC Sawgrass despite not having his A game.
    James scores 35, Cavs take 3-0 lead with 115-94 victory

    James scores 35, Cavs take 3-0 lead with 115-94 victory

    The offense hasn't been stopped as Cleveland has reeled off 116, 125 and 115 points in the first three wins, respectively. Norman Powell made Toronto's first 3-pointer with 3:09 in the third quarter - the Raptors were 0-of-12 up to that point.
    Trump hails China trade deal ending ban on beef

    Trump hails China trade deal ending ban on beef

    The two sides didn't discuss whether the USA would join the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank, Ross said. Coming a month after Presidents Donald Trump and Xi Jinping met in Florida, it allowed China to depict Mr.
  • Toyota, 3 other automakers settle suit over Takata air bags

    Toyota, 3 other automakers settle suit over Takata air bags

    Officials pointed out that economic loss claims pending against Ford, Honda and Nissan will continue to be prosecuted. They began in 2008 and cover around 100 million airbag inflators used in vehicles made by 19 automakers.

    SK envoys to hold talks in China

    While taking the oath of office Wednesday, Moon said he's open to visiting North Korea under the right conditions. South Korea's election body said that Moon had gathered 41 percent of the votes.
    Indians promote top OF prospect Zimmer

    Indians promote top OF prospect Zimmer

    This has been a fact ever since joining the Indians organization, striking out 43 times this season in 33 games. In Columbus this season Zimmer enters hitting.323 against left handed pitching while batting.294 overall.
  • Residents of Pyongyang, Seoul comment on test of new missile

    United States officials said the missile hit the water around 60 miles (around 100 kilometers) from eastern Russia's Vladivostok. Australia's prime minister has called on China to use its leverage over North Korea to end the regime's missile testing.
    Musk teases first look at Boring Company tunnel and 'electric sled'

    Musk teases first look at Boring Company tunnel and 'electric sled'

    It looks like they are using their hyperloop test track to test the electric sled concept and not the tunnel itself. The idea is that automobiles could drive onto the skates at street level, and then be lowered into rail tunnels.

    Simona Halep beats Kristina Mladenovic to defend Madrid Open title

    She's a very tough opponent, very hard to play against her. "I think it was a great final". But now I feel good because I played doubles and I relaxed my body.
  • That's Sanchez - Wenger hails Arsenal match-winner

    Midfielder Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain had picked up a hamstring injury but Wenger said that the injury was not serious. Petr Cech made two crucial saves to ensure Arsenal went into the first half break on level terms with the Saints.
    SLIDESHOW: Top baby names for 2016 revealed

    SLIDESHOW: Top baby names for 2016 revealed

    Since the now commander-in-chief started his campaign trail, the name Donald has decreased in popularity among new parents. In general, she said, parents don't want to give their children names that might attract controversy.
    US sees Iran working to preserve nuclear deal

    US sees Iran working to preserve nuclear deal

    Assad will maintain military strength as long as Iran and Russian Federation, two of his key allies, keep backing him, Coats said. But he warned that "left unchecked, that stalemate will deteriorate in the favor of belligerence".

CONNECT